« Deal reached for roads to new Deloitte U. in Westlake | Main | Tollway authority ready to open its books, answer criticisms about hefty toll late fees, cozy relationship with contractors »

April 28, 2011

Could Texas someday track drivers electronically, charge a vehicle-mile-traveled tax instead of a gas tax?

Here's a question for you: Would you rather pay the current state gas tax of 20 cents a gallon (on top of the federal tax of 18.4 cents a gallon) or instead pay a tax based on how much you actually drive?

A lot of people who are trying to solving the state's funding crisis are quietly talking about the feasibility of someday tracking Texas drivers and charging people only on the amount of road they actually use. As many cars become more fuel efficient, and cars that run on electricity or other fuels become more popular, states are eventually going to have to find an alternative to levying a gasoline or diesel tax. Taxing drivers on vehicle miles traveled is something that theoretically can be done with today's technology.

But others think there's no way Texans will go along with such a system, which smacks of electronic surveillance and Big Brotherism ...Vehiclemilestraveled

In any case, today the Texas Transportation Commission is getting a briefing about a pilot program that's about to launch in Minnesota. In the program, a group of Minnesota drivers will carry special mobile phones that track their movements beginning in July, and pay a per-mile fee based on how many miles they travel. The beauty of this science is, motorists can also be charged a higher fee for traveling during peak times of day, when space on the roads is at a premium, and they can travel at a much lower rate when the roads are clear.

The Texas commissioners are very interested in this subject, and are asking a lot of questions of the Minnesota representative, whose name is Ben Pierce of the high-tech firm Battelle.

Commission chairwoman Deirdre Delisi of Austin noted the recent controversy that has brewed worldwide after it became known that Apple can readily track its iPhone users with technology that's already in the phone. Delisi asked a question to the effect of, if the state promises the pilot project participants that they're not being tracked for ulterior reasons -- i.e. spying -- will the citizens believe it?

Pierce noted that participation would be voluntary, and that those who didn't want to carry a phone to track their vehicle miles could simply go back to paying a flat rate for their tax.

He said that while some would object to being tracked, the attitude of others is "I'm carrying the phone anyway, so it's not much difference. It's a discount system. If you don't want to use the phone in your car, don't. Just pay the flat rate."

Commissioner Ned Holmes of Houston thanked Pierce for his briefing. "We look forward to hearing from you," Holmes said. "When are you coming back."

Pierce said he could provide the Texas panel on how the Minnesota program is working as soon as October or November.

-- Gordon Dickson, gdickson@star-telegram.com

Twitter: @gdickson


TrackBack URL for this entry:

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Could Texas someday track drivers electronically, charge a vehicle-mile-traveled tax instead of a gas tax?:



There you go, punish the people who have social responsibility and make a sacrifice by driving fuel efficient vehicles and reward the guy who's trying to make up for his own "shortcomings" and can't move away from the mega truck. I guess bubba came up with this

JR McIntyre

They got it half right. Base the tax on the number of miles driven AND gross vehicle weight. It's not just the number of miles you drive that wears on the roads...it's also the weight. I know, tank trucks carrying water to gas drill sights have totaled the roads in my area....


You're not being punished, you use the roads tha same as I do and you should pay your fair share of the upkeep. I pay plenty of taxes for my diesel pickup, but nowhere near what I would be paying for the same truck with a comparable gas engine. I think everybody driving a car that gets more than 30MPG should be forced to pay by the mile to ensure they are paying their fair share. Motorcycles should be exempt from this and just pay the fuel tax since they don't wear the road surface by any appreciable amount.


so punish more people who own their own business and drive for a living. why not get rid of both taxes since they stick us everywhere else for money they don't spend wisely like highway landscaping.


This is amazing. You combine state and federal tax and insinuate that it might be better to have a miles driven charge in lieu? Yeah right...Would the fuel be free?? Probably on top of the fuel charge you would have the miles charge.

The comments to this entry are closed.